The two major awards this year have gone to violent films, the Oscar and Berlin. What does this say about cinema and the critics and juries? Tropa de Elite may not be a great film but it does not warrant some of the very strong criticism it has also received. It is an important film because of the impact it causes, shocking you with its grim depiction of police corruption and violence in the favelas of Rio. As it is based on real stories, we have to see it as being reasonably authentic and certainly reports from Brazil suggest it to be so. And it is an ugly tale that it has to tell. In it, we see the endemic, uncontrollable and senseless corruption in the police force, buying and selling everything, graft and bribes galore. Filmed with a dizzying speed, hand-held cameras and all different angles, it is almost too much to take in, but one suspects that this is also part of the everyday life in the force there. Then we have the idealistic rich kids helping in the favelas and becoming embroiled in all the drug use and trafficking and finally the BOPE, or elite squad that goes in when the police can’t cope and has barbaric training and initiation ceremonies. All this leads to a picture of us as a decadent civilization where limits were not set when they should have been and we are left with a mess that is going to be nigh impossible to fix. The same Latin American recipe of corrupt police, excluded urban poor and ready guns and drugs is clear here and for my money Jose Padilha translates it to the screen in all its glory. He uses a similar style to City of God to give us this powerful effect and make us believe we are actually in the crossfire as it were. Apart from this style, the cast is fine, especially Wagner Moura as Nascimento the jaded police captain who is far from in control as he would like to think.
Read the rest of this entry ... (30 words left)